Madden Ratings: Top 10 QB's

Aaron Rodgers: 99
Tom Brady: 98
Drew Brees: 98
Eli Manning: 97
Ben Roethlisberger: 95
Peyton Manning: 93
Philip Rivers: 92
Matthew Stafford: 91
Tony Romo: 90
Michael Vick: 89

What do you guys think?

I like it. You can argue a spot here or there but a pretty solid top 10.

My QB in the top ten, ill take it

I can't argue with the top 10 too much, but I think the ratings are still too inflated. Honestly feel that starting with Eli, he should be a 95 (moved down 2 overall) and everyone else should get a 2 overall rating drop as well.

Where that hell is Alex Smith??? Another Madden snub

Betta_thanu wrote:Where that hell is Alex Smith??? Another Madden snub

He's better yes, but top 10 is absurd.

ELI IS 97!!!???????

TheDarkKnight50 wrote:

Betta_thanu wrote:Where that hell is Alex Smith??? Another Madden snub

He's better yes, but top 10 is absurd.

Co-Sign. Lol

psychomantis930 wrote:ELI IS 97!!!???????

No excuse for not winning your division this year psycho

indo501 wrote:

TheDarkKnight50 wrote:

Betta_thanu wrote:Where that hell is Alex Smith??? Another Madden snub

He's better yes, but top 10 is absurd.

Co-Sign. Lol

lol, thats BS, look at last season's stats....P Rivers not even there



http://www.nfl.com/stats/categorystats?tabSeq=0&statisticCategory=PASSING&conference=null&season=2011&seasonType=POST&d-447263-s=PASSING_YARDS&d-447263-o=2&d-447263-n=1

Thanks for the post Mowarrior79! Oh Kolb and Skelton, you're not making this QB decision for me any easier..

WHAT!? NO MATT HASSELBECK IN THE TOP 10!??!?!?! get outta here.. these ratings are rigged!